Committee
Consult the user guide
For assistance, please contact us
Consult the user guide
For assistance, please contact us
Add search criteria
Results: 31 - 45 of 687
View Gabriel Ste-Marie Profile
BQ (QC)
I am extremely disappointed to hear such nonsense being given as an answer.
In the United States, a senate committee held an inquiry that has changed things. It is our role to do that here. My role as an elected representative, and our role as a committee, is to ask the minister to initiate a public inquiry to get to the bottom of things. There are enough points to be raised to ask for that.
We are not getting any answers, other than being told to change jobs. What a load of nonsense. She is the one who has the power.
Is she going to do it, yes or no?
View Diane Lebouthillier Profile
Lib. (QC)
Mr. Chair, I am going to ask my colleague to vote on budget 2021, which sets out proposals that really are even more useful for eliminating the loopholes used to avoid paying taxes in Canada, and that allocate additional money to the CRA so that it can modernize and improve its capacities.
In addition to all the work done and the agreements signed by the countries, I am also very happy to see that the United States has embarked on the same path. We are therefore going to work in collaboration with our partners. As I said at the outset, this is a long and complex issue, and I understand very well that the public are offended. We are continuing our work and we truly want to combat tax evasion. This is a priority for our government.
View Peter Julian Profile
NDP (BC)
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.
I also want to wish you a happy birthday. Someday we will celebrate together, I'm sure.
I would like to welcome the minister and Mr. Gallivan.
I'm going to continue in the same vein as Mr. Ste‑Marie.
We are talking about thousands of Canadians, victims who have lost all their life savings. We know very well that in the frauds committed by Norshield and Mount Real, there are thousands of Canadians who lost everything. The system has never got justice for them.
Minister, you have been the minister for six years. What do you say to the victims, like Janet Watson who appeared before the committee, who say that the government has done absolutely nothing to protect them or to bring the guilty parties to justice?
View Diane Lebouthillier Profile
Lib. (QC)
Mr. Chair, I thank my colleague for his question. We know that I have very sincere sympathy for the people who have been victims of fraud, just as he does. I truly understand how much this can affect their lives.
However, as I said, and it doesn't bother me to repeat it, our government respects the CRA's status. I can't instruct the CRA to initiate audits and I do not intervene in audits. This is what protects the integrity of the tax system. We are going to continue doing the work we do, and because we want to keep moving forward, I invite my colleague to vote for the budget that has been introduced. It contains even greater resources to tighten the net and make sure that people pay their fair share.
If my colleague wishes to get any more technical and administrative information, Mr. Gallivan can answer him.
View Peter Julian Profile
NDP (BC)
I would like to get back to the question of the Panama Papers, the Bahama Leaks and the Paradise Papers.
All those papers, which are publicly available, contain almost 6,000 numbers of Canadian companies and names of Canadian individuals who benefited from a whole range of tax loopholes outside Canada.
It's a simple question: how many of those companies and those individuals, who have been named for six years now, have been charged? How many of them have been convicted?
View Diane Lebouthillier Profile
Lib. (QC)
Mr. Chair, we are taking on very wealthy people. These people have the resources to pay the best lawyers, the best tax law experts, and the best teams to defend them.
Canada adheres to the rule of law, and these people use all legal means available to them to ensure that they do not pay their fair share.
I invite my colleague to support the budget so we can provide the resources to do even more to deal with those who commit fraud.
View Peter Julian Profile
NDP (BC)
You have not answered my question.
Mr. Gallivan, how many charges have been laid? How many convictions have there been?
Ted Gallivan
View Ted Gallivan Profile
Ted Gallivan
2021-06-22 16:39
As was said earlier, the investigations have not resulted in convictions at this point.
View Peter Julian Profile
NDP (BC)
That means that there have been no charges or convictions concerning the Isle of Man; no convictions relating to the Panama Papers; none in connection with the Bahama Leaks; and none concerning the Paradise Papers.
There have therefore been no convictions in six years.
You said in this committee in 2016 that we were talking about measures taken to get information about electronic funds transfers. Regarding the CRA's audits of electronic funds transfers in excess of $10,000, how many files are now subject to criminal prosecution? How many convictions are there?
We see Cinar, and we see the lack of action with the Isle of Man scam. We see that there have been absolutely no charges ever levied in all of these very clear violations of our tax code. I remind the minister, of course, of the comments made by Brigitte Unger, professor of economics, who said that this is effectively stealing money from public coffers, yet we see no action at all.
When it comes to electronic funds transfers, how many files are now subject to criminal prosecution?
View Diane Lebouthillier Profile
Lib. (QC)
As I have said multiple times since the meeting began, these are very complex cases.
I would ask my colleague not to act as if he doesn't understand simple things. If I were to interfere in criminal investigations, I would be before the committee being accused of exactly the opposite.
View Peter Julian Profile
NDP (BC)
It's simple; there has been a total failure for six years. There have been no prosecutions and no convictions.
I would like to ask you another question.
Tax audited files reported to the CRA by the criminal prosecution service have decreased over the last 10 years by 86%. Could the minister explain, when there's been no success in any of these areas we've just talked about, why even the tax audit files forwarded by the CRA to the Canadian criminal prosecution service have decreased by such a substantial amount, 86% since just before her term?
Ted Gallivan
View Ted Gallivan Profile
Ted Gallivan
2021-06-22 16:42
I'm not sure where the 86% came from. There has been a decrease in the referrals because we are focusing on more serious cases. I think similarly that complexity is what's driving the lack of convictions in relation to the Panama papers.
There's a high evidentiary standard. It takes the Crown a long time to put its case together. The fact that there's nothing to date shouldn't indicate that there will never be anything.
View Tamara Jansen Profile
CPC (BC)
Thank you.
Madam Minister, at committee we've spent almost 30 hours wading through a ton of incredibly complex tax changes while studying the BIA. Everyone agrees that the tax act is overly complex. As a matter of fact, it's so complex that even your own team at the call centres gave Canadian taxpayers false or erroneous information 30% of the time, so even your own people don't understand it.
Small businesses are spending an exorbitant amount of money and time trying to comply. Under your watch, it has become even more difficult and leaves small business owners in constant fear of accidentally being non-compliant.
Would you commit today to Canadians to simplify the system so that they can stop wasting their precious time trying to wade through piles of incomprehensible tax rules?
View Diane Lebouthillier Profile
Lib. (QC)
Mr. Chair, I would like to tell my colleague that if she wants to change the laws, the Minister of National Revenue is not who she should be talking to; it's the Minister of Finance. The Minister of Finance is who prepares the legislation. At the Canada Revenue Agency, we just apply it.
View Tamara Jansen Profile
CPC (BC)
I'll pass it on to my colleague. I find that an absolutely unacceptable answer.
Results: 31 - 45 of 687 | Page: 3 of 46

|<
<
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
>
>|
Export As: XML CSV RSS

For more data options, please see Open Data