Skip to main content
Start of content

The Hansard Index is the key to information about what is said by Members of Parliament in the House of Commons during the 37th Parliament, 2nd Session. The subject entries will either provide reference to a page number or, a combination of page number followed by the issue sitting number and time checks in the daily Hansard.

To use the Index, select one of the alphabetical ranges below. When you have located your subject entry, click on the numbers within brackets to access the relevant text in the Debates. You may also use the “Publication Search” tool for content published after January 2001.

If you have any questions or comments regarding the accessibility of this publication, please contact us at accessible@parl.gc.ca.

37th Parliament, 2nd Session   (September 30, 2002 - November 12, 2003)  Current Session
35-1 .
35-2 .
36-1 .
36-2 .
37-1 .
37-2 .
37-3 .
38-1 .
39-1 .
39-2 .
40-1 .
40-2 .
40-3 .
41-1 .
41-2 .
42-1 .
43-1 .
43-2 .
44-1
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024

Mergers see Airlines; Banks and financial institutions; BioChem Pharma Inc.; Corporations; Great-West Lifeco Inc.; Transportation

Meritorious Service Medal

    >>Jellinek, Captain Michael, recipient, S.O. 31, 8773(144:1410)

Merrifield, Rob (CA--Yellowhead)

Merritt Mountain Music Fest

    >>Merritt, BC, Country must festival, S.O. 31, 5017(83:1410)

MERX system see Government contracts--Solicitor General Department, Treasury Board guidelines

Metalclad Corporation

    >>North American Free Trade Agreement Chapter 11 lawsuit, Mexico factor, 5134(84:1800-5), 5134(84:1810)

Metallurgical coal industry see Coal mining industry

Metals see Heavy metals

Meteorites

    >>Non-existence, French academy of science 18th century position, 2158(36:2045)

Meteorological Service of Canada

    >>Advisory board, Weather Network executive membership, conflict of interest possibility, o.q., 8038(131:1500)
    >>Centralization/rationalization of weather forecasting, impact, o.q., 3301(55:1135), 8038(131:1500)
    >>Changes, March 31, 2003, documents, M. for Production of Papers (Wasylycia-Leis), called, transferred for debate, 8906(146:1540)
    >>Fredericton, NB forecast centre, move to Halifax, NS
    >>>Petitions, 7755(126:1535)
    >>>S.O. 31, 4584(76:1405)
    >>Gander, NL weather station, downsizing
    >>>o.q., 6680(108:1455)
    >>>Petitions, 6859(111:1540)
    >>>qu., 7346(119:1540)
    >>>S.O. 31, 4361(72:1410), 5354(88:1410)
    >>Government funding
    >>>Cutbacks, 4797(79:1150)
    >>>o.q., 4252(71:1500)
    >>>S.O. 31, 4243(71:1405)
    >>Mountain Weather Office, Kelowna, BC, closure possibility, avalanche forecasting role, o.q., 3183-4(53:1500)
    >>Quebec City, QC offices, status, Montreal, QC, relocation possibility
    >>>o.q., 797(13:1455)
    >>>qu., 7345-6(119:1540)
    >>Rimouski, QC office, closure possibility, o.q., 2332(39:1450)
    >>Weather stations, closing, 4005(67:1705), 4811(79:1345)
    >>>Agriculture and Agri-Food Department funding, requesting, o.q., 4042(68:1505)
    >>>o.q., 4865(80:1155)
    >>>S.O. 31, 4243(71:1405)
    >>Winnipeg, MB, weather office, status, o.q., 4865(80:1155)
    >>See also Hurricanes--Hurricane Juan

Methane

    >>Energy role, carbon dioxide sequestration in coal beds, greenhouse gas emissions reduction role, 1893(32:1310), 1927(32:1715), 2399(40:1410)
    >>See also Municipal waste--Landfill sites, Greenhouse gas emissions factor; Sewage systems--Biogas systems

Methyl tertiary-butyl ether see MTBE (methyl tertiary-butyl ether)

Methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl see MMT (methylcyclopentadienyl manganese tricarbonyl)

Métis see Regional development--Saskatchewan; Riel, Louis David

Metis veterans see Veterans' benefits/pensions--Aboriginal and Metis veterans

Métivier, Paul

    >>World War I veteran, Queen's Golden Jubilee Medal recipient, tribute, S.O. 31, 4911(81:1400)

Metric system

Metro

    >>Sorin, Corinne, chief editor, appointment, Sébastien St-Hilaire, sales and marketing director, S.O. 31, 7525(122:1410)

MetroStar awards

    >>Quebec television awards, winners, congratulating, S.O. 31, 4243(71:1405), 4360(72:1410)

Mexico

    >>Canales, Fernando, Economics Secretary see North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA)--Future
    >>Union representation votes, requiring secret ballot, Canadian complaint under North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), relationship, o.q., 3180(53:1445)
    >>See also Canada-Mexico relations; Export Development Canada (EDC)--Union Pacific Railroad; Federalism; Iraq, United States pre-emptive attack; Metalclad Corporation

Meyer, Joanne see Ethics--Cabinet Ministers--Hiring; Health Department--JM Enterprises

Mi, Tao see Immigration--Lai immigration hearing

Michelin, Steve

    >>Labrador constituent, community leader, death, tribute, S.O. 31, 3640(61:1400)

Microbreweries see Breweries

Middle class

Middle East

    >>Secretary of State for Central and Eastern Europe and the Middle East Knutson visit, o.q., 137(3:1455)
    >>See also Iraq, United States pre-emptive attack

Middle East conflict

    >>Canadian position, 188(3:2130-5)
    >>>Graham, Foreign Affairs Minister, February 11, 2003, speech to National Council on Canadian Arab Relations dinner, S.O. 31, 3461(58:1410)
    >>Corrie, Rachel, killed by Israeli army bulldozer, S.O. 31, 4360(72:1410), 4409(73:1405)
    >>Gaza area, peace activists, Israeli government injury or death waiver demand, o.q., 6968-9(113:1145)
    >>Iraq, United States pre-emptive attack, impact, S.O. 31, 4360(72:1410)
    >>Israeli occupied territories
    >>>Human rights violations, S.O. 31, 467(7:1405), 5285(87:1400)
    >>>Petitions, 4923(81:1505)
    >>Palestinian refugee camps, Khan Younis refugee camp, October 7, 2002 Israeli raid, S.O. 31, 507(8:1415)
    >>Palestinians, relocation from West Bank and Gaza, Israel Knesset member, Benny Elon, proposal, S.O. 31, 4655-6(77:1410)
    >>Peace process
    >>>Canadian government position, o.q., 6967(113:1135)
    >>>United States President George W. Bush, contribution, S.O. 31, 6911-2(112:1400)
    >>Road map for peace, monitors, Canada role, S.O. 31, 7284(118:1110)
    >>Suicide bombers, Hezbollah terrorist group, political wing leader, Sheik Hassan Nasrallah remarks, S.O. 31, 2423(41:1405)
    >>West Bank fence, security wall, S.O. 31, 8965(147:1405)
    >>See also Arafat, Yasser; Said, Edward W.

Middle income Canadians see Tax reductions--Low and middle income Canadians

Middle Powers Initiative (MPI) see Nuclear weapons--Eliminating

Migratory birds see Highways and roads--Ontario, Hamilton, ON; Simon Fraser University--Centre for Wildlife Ecology

Migué, Laurent

    >>Association de Repentigny pour l'avancement de la musique, founder, Governor General's Caring Canadian Award, recipient, S.O. 31, 5352(88:1405)

MIL Davie Inc. see Davie Industries Inc./MIL Davie Inc.

Miles for Mental Health see Mental illness--Casey

Milit-Air Inc. see Government grants and contributions--Bombardier Inc.

Military judges

Military justice system

    >>Judge Advocate General (JAG) Office, role, 5819(95:1615)
    >>National Defence Act (amdt.)(Bill C-25)(1st. Sess., 36th Parl.), independent review and government response, tabled, 9195(151:1525)
    >>See also DNA evidence--Samples

Military memorial sites

    >>Overseas, high school student visits, financial assistance, 8355-6(137:1010)
    >>>See also Overseas Memorial Sites Student Visits Act (Bill C-455)

Milk producers see Dairy industry

Mill Cove, NS see Citizenship--Ceremonies

Millennium Excellence Award see Canada Millennium Scholarship Foundation

Millennium scholarship fund

    >>Accountability of funds, lack, 3895(66:1240)
    >>Establishment, role, etc., 37(2:1300), 3732(62:1630), 3763(63:1640), 3926(66:1625), 4004(67:1650)
    >>Grants, means based, replacing, proposed, 4275(71:1705)
    >>Ontario government $3000 clawback, 3772(63:1745)
    >>Payments made/funds available, 2602(44:1115)
    >>Provincial jurisdiction, federal intrusion, 62(2:1535)

Miller, Bob see New Brunswick Multimedia Award of Excellence

Miller, Marliese see Curling--World Junior Curling Championships

Milliken, Hon. Peter (Lib.--Kingston and the Islands; Speaker)

    >>Auditor General's reports, 433(7:1000), 2200(37:1400), 5241(86:1405)
    >>Bills, Senate, 9194(151:1515)
    >>Board of Internal Economy, 1082(18:1530), 2689(46:1100)
    >>Canadian Human Rights Tribunal, 4921(81:1500)
    >>Chairman/Acting Chairman, rulings and statements, question and comment period, 1410(23:2200), 1413(23:2220)
    >>Chief Electoral Officer, 4921(81:1500)
    >>Christmas season, 2686(45:1200)
    >>Cloutier, Major-General Maurice Gaston, 1080(18:1515)
    >>Commissioner of Official Languages, 207(4:1000)
    >>Duhamel, Hon. Senator Ron J., 48(2:1415)
    >>Environment and Sustainable Development Commissioner, 713(12:1000), 8246(135:1025)
    >>Federal Electoral Boundaries Commissions, 2723(46:1520), 3471(58:1510), 3915(66:1500), 4105(69:1005), 4253(71:1505), 4718(78:1500), 7297(118:1220)
    >>House of Commons, 1494(25:1115)
    >>House of Commons calendar, 8007(130:1635)
    >>House of Commons Pages, 7299(118:1225)
    >>House of Commons proceedings, 48(2:1415), 1503(25:1200), 4783(79:1005), 5443(90:1410), 8090(132:1210), 8638(142:1045)
    >>House of Commons vacancies, 4217(71:1105), 4370(72:1505), 7305(119:1105)
    >>House of Commons visitors, 57(2:1500), 317(5:1200), 365(6:1500), 755(12:1500), 798(13:1500), 869(14:1500), 1035(17:1500), 1078(18:1500), 1146-7(19:1500), 1307-8(22:1500), 1353(23:1505), 1503(25:1200), 1551(26:1500), 1658(28:1500-5), 1841(31:1500), 1910(32:1500), 1949(33:1500), 2212(37:1505), 2635(44:1500), 2713(46:1415), 2721(46:1505), 2846(48:1500), 3141(52:1500), 3184(53:1500), 3254(54:1500), 3353(56:1415), 3470(58:1500), 3651(61:1500), 3720(62:1500), 3747(63:1500), 4369(72:1500), 4420(73:1505), 4493(74:1500), 4664(77:1500), 4995(82:1500), 5250(86:1500), 5362-3(88:1500-5), 5452(90:1500), 5714(93:1505), 5813(95:1500), 5871(96:1500), 6089(100:1500), 6246(102:1505), 6539(106:1500), 6742(109:1500), 6855(111:1510), 6923(112:1500), 7030(114:1500), 7219(117:1500), 7339(119:1500), 7419(120:1500), 7460(121:1505), 7535(122:1500), 7631(124:1500), 7920(129:1500), 8039(131:1505), 8214(134:1500), 8490(139:1500), 8781(144:1500), 8976(147:1500), 9079(149:1500), 9149(150:1500), 9192(151:1505), 9271(152:1500), 9276(152:1540), 9319(153:1200)
    >>Members of Parliament, 2713(46:1415-20), 6430(105:1415), 7330-1(119:1415), 9111(150:1005)
    >>Modernization and Improvement of the Procedures of the House of Commons Special Committee, 4217(71:1105)
    >>Parliament, 37th Parl., 2nd Sess., opening, 1(1:1400)
    >>Parliamentary delegations, reports, 1791(30:1210), 6881(112:1005), 8041(131:1520), 8604(141:1505)
    >>Privacy Commissioner
    >>>2001-2002 annual report, 2839(48:1415)
    >>>2002-2003 annual report, 7460(121:1505)
    >>>Auditor General special report, 7952(130:1005)
    >>>Provincial legislation, substantially similar, 2003 report, 7143(116:1510)
    >>Private Members' Business, 4217(71:1105)
    >>Privilege
    >>>Ablonczy (contempt of Parliament), Coderre, Minister of Citizenship and Immigration and departmental officials deliberately misleading Citizenship and Immigration Standing Committee on number of backlog of refugee claimant cases, court confirming misleading information provided, Minister/department failure to correct, taking under advisement, 6546(106:1545), Member did not identify specific misleading statements in allegations, Chair not willing to consider Minister deliberately misleading Committee, matter of debate, not question of privilege, 7296-7(118:1210-5)
    >>>Augustine (language, inappropriate/improper), Pallister remarks "Finally a Sheila that makes sense", displaying disrespect for women, taking under advisement, 2261(38:1535)
    >>>Boudria (rights of Members breached), British Columbia Court of Appeal, Ontario Superior Court rulings, denial of 40 day rule under Member's right to refuse to answer a subpoena to attend as witness before a court of law, taking under advisement, 6093(100:1530), privilege of House and Members well established as matter of parliamentary law and privilege in Canada today and must be respected by the courts, prima facie breach of privilege of House and Members, Member invited to move motion, 6411-3(105:1205-20)
    >>>Breitkreuz (contempt of Parliament)
    >>>>Justice Department deliberately providing false information in reply to Order Paper question relating to firearms registry, taking under advisement, 2260(38:1530), no evidence of deliberate attempt to provide false or inaccurate information, no procedural grounds for breach of privilege, not question of privilege, 2637-8(44:1515-20)
    >>>>Justice Minister Cauchon failure to table documents as required by statute and decision of Chair on earlier question of privilege, taking under advisement, 6856(111:1520), statements of reasons for all regulations properly tabled, not question of privilege, 6924)112:1505)
    >>>>Government transferring responsibility for the Canadian Firearms Program from Minister of Justice to Solicitor General without amending enabling legislation, use of regulation/Order in Council, ignoring intent of Parliament, taking under advisement, 5719(93:1540), question of superior and subordinate acts one of legality, Chair does not have authority to rule on questions of law, unable to find breach of privilege, 6121-2(101:1010)
    >>>Breitkreuz (false/misleading statements)
    >>>>Justice Minister Cauchon deliberately misleading House and preventing Members from fulfilling duties by failure to table in House documents relating to Firearms Registry, taking under advisement, 3186(53:1520), House received one set of documents while a more complete set of material was available outside House but no procedural obligation existed for minister to table these documents in first place, regrettable but not question of privilege, 3506-7(59:1015-20)
    >>>>Justice Minister Cauchon misleading statements re information requested by Members of Parliament and Auditor General concerning Canadian Firearms Centre and the gun registry program, taking under advisement, 7342(119:1520), not question of privilege, 8040-1(131:1510-5)
    >>>>Solicitor General Easter misleading House concerning funding of Canadian Firearms Program, Chair will hear further submission from Government House Leader to clarify alleged conflicting items in estimates, 7752(126:1520), taking under advisement, no evidence Solicitor General incorrect, not question of privilege, 8243-5(135:1005-10)
    >>>Bryden (contempt of Parliament) judiciary usurping power of Parliament to legislate, taking under advisement, 7343(119:1530), not question of privilege, 7951(130:1000-5)
    >>>Byrne (false/misleading statements), allegations by several Members that Minister participated in fund raising efforts re Viking millennium celebrations while Minister of State, grievance, not question of privilege, 7296(118:1210)
    >>>Chatters (false/misleading statements), Natural Resources Minister Dhaliwal failure to answer question re constituents freedom to contact Members of Parliament on ethanol expansion program, Members of Parliament not government officials, allowing Minister opportunity to clarify answer, 9150(150:1505)
    >>>Clark (contempt of Parliament)
    >>>>Government advertising promoting Kyoto Protocol attempting to sway public opinion prior to Parliament making decision, advertising did not indicate decision fait accompli, not question of privilege, 1822-3(31:1310-5)
    >>>>Justice Department/Minister taking action exactly contrary to decision by Parliament to denying spending, reserving right to raise matter at later date, Chair acknowledging Member's right to raise question of privilege at later date if necessary, 2638-9(44:1525)
    >>>>Privacy Commissioner accusing several Members of House of violation of Privacy Act, reporting in media instead of reporting to House, Privacy Commissioner may report but is not required to report to Parliament exclusively, not question of privilege, 1820(31:1245)
    >>>Clark (false/misleading statements)
    >>>>Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) reply to order paper question relating to security expenditures at Kananaskis G-8 Summit inaccurate and incomplete, contempt of House of Commons, reserving right to raise at later date, 1790-1(30:1205)
    >>>>Hubbard comment re absence of Mark from Committee meetings, debate, not question of privilege, 6891(112:1115)
    >>>Cummins (contempt of Parliament), Canadian Coast Guard Commissioner directive to Coast Guard employees to report, within 24 hours, inquiries from or contact with Members of Parliament, Members not intimidated, cannot control how employees feel, other opportunities to discuss matters with Coast Guard employees, not question of privilege, 7996(130:1510)
    >>>Dalphond-Guiral (false/misleading statements), Prime Minister Chrétien misquoting/quoting out of context remarks re suitability of George Radwanksi to be Privacy Commissioner, matter of debate, not question of privilege, 7995(130:1505)
    >>>Davies (contempt of Parliament)
    >>>>Canadian Armed Forces members serving in military action in Iraq, violation of adopted motion of House and contrary to statements by Prime Minister, motion not direction to government, not question of privilege, 4825-6(79:1505)
    >>>>Justice Minister Cauchon discussion proposed marijuana legislation with United States officials prior to tabling bill in House of Commons, no evidence Minister to make available copies of bill to someone else, not question of privilege, 6173(101:1610)
    >>>Davies (rights of Members breached)
    >>>>Notice of time allocation motion improperly moved in Aboriginal Affairs, Northern Development and Natural Resources Standing Committee, cutting off study of bill, matter fully within jurisdiction of Committee, matter best settled in Committee, 5040-1(83:1540)
    >>>>Wayne remarks re gays and lesbians, offensive, denial of rights of Members to speak, Member may not agree with remarks but Member entitled to make remarks, Members not prevented from expressing disagreement with remarks, not question of privilege, 9036-7(99:1205-10)
    >>>Gallant (false/misleading statements), O'Reilly, Parliamentary Secretary to Minister of National Defence deliberately misleading House re closure of Emergency Preparedness College, Arnprior, ON., taking under advisement, 965(16:1510), 1035(17:1505), no evidence to suggest breach of privilege, dispute as to facts, not question of privilege, 1080(18:1520)
    >>>Gallaway (contempt of Parliament), Justice Minister Cauchon continuing to fund/operate gun registry in spite of denial of additional funding under supplementary estimates, taking under advisement, 3475(58:1535), withdrawal or defeat of supplementary estimates request relating to Firearms Registry program does not cancel program, no procedural irregularities, not question of privilege, 3651-3(61:1500-10)
    >>>Godin (language, inappropriate/improper), Pankiw accusing Members of hiding behind white sheet and being the equivalent of modern day Klansmen, taking under advisement, 1622(27:1505), 1660(28:1525), language unparliamentary, withdrawal requested, 1949(33:1505-10)
    >>>Godin (rights of Members breached), Bonin, Chair, Aboriginal Affairs, Northern Development and Natural Resources Standing Committee, refusal to allow Comartin to complete remarks on motion to summon witness before Committee, taking under advisement, 1739-40(29:1505-10), 1842(31:1510), 1913(32:1520), committee to conduct business before it, matter remains within committee to deal with, not question of privilege, 1949-50(33:1510-5)
    >>>Hearn (false/misleading statements), Parliamentary Secretary to Minister of Public Works giving conflicting statements on Royal Canadian Mounted Police investigation of alleged Royal LePage contract scandal, statements may be confusing but no evidence of inadequate or wrong information provided, other opportunities for Member to seek clarification, not question of privilege, 7754(126:1525)
    >>>Lee (contempt of Parliament), George Radwanski, former Privacy Commissioner, deliberately misleading Government Operations and Estimates Standing Committee relating to expenditures and conducting operations of Privacy Commissioner Office, taking under advisement, 9151(150:1520), 9193(151:1515)
    >>>Lill (language, inappropriate/improper), Finance Minister Manley remarks that Elley personalizing issue of disability tax credit, remarks insulting and offensive, withdrawal requested, matter of debate, not question of privilege, 517(8:1505)
    >>>Loubier (rights of Members breached), Bonin, Chair, Aboriginal Affairs, Northern Development and Natural Resources Standing Committee interference in consultations with committee clerk, refusal to allow Committee to report to House, verbally abusive of witnesses and Committee members, displaying bias in decisions, committee business mismanaged, atmosphere of distrust fostered, no report received from Committee, matter must be dealt with by Committee, 7175-6(117:1005)
    >>>MacKay (contempt of House of Commons), Senate dividing Criminal Code (amdt.--cruelty to animals and firearms) and Firearms Act (amdt.)(Bill C-10), infringing on prerogatives of House, taking under advisement, 2302(39:1125), Senate seeking concurrence of House to divide, House to debate motion, not question of privilege, 2334-6(39:1500-10)
    >>>Mahoney (rights of Members breached), Rob Anders request that Members sign draft letter to Prime Minister on House of Commons letterhead relating to Falun Gong issue, taking under advisement, 3989(67:1515), no misrepresentation or attempt of interfere, not question of privilege, 4253(71:1505)
    >>>Ménard (rights of Members breached), Special Committee on Non-Medical Use of Drugs, minority report, unauthorized disclosure, 2639-40(44:1525-35), taking under advisement, 2640(44:1535), 2736(46:1535), 3256(54:1525), none of remarks quoted in media constitute direct disclosure of contents of report, not question of privilege, 3505-6(59:1010-5)
    >>>Pankiw (contempt of Parliament), Public Service managers/employees instructing other Public Service employees not to reply to Pankiw questionnaire/survey relating to bilingualism in the Public Service, taking under advisement, 2848(48:1510), survey not conducted in context of proceedings of House or Committee, parliamentary privilege does not apply, not question of privilege, 3470-1(58:1500-5)
    >>>Reynolds (contempt of Parliament)
    >>>>Goods and Service Tax (GST), fraudulent refund claims, Minister of National Revenue, tabling report, legislative requirement, failure to comply, taking under advisement, 2412(41:1215), matter of debate, not question of privilege, 2600-1(44:1100-5)
    >>>>Procedure and House Affairs Standing Committee, report re: Private Members' Business, votable items, referral to modernization committee, departure from Order of Reference, taking under advisement, 2564(43:1530), no procedural irregularity, not a question of privilege, 2636-7(44:1505-15)
    >>>>Treasury Board President Robillard attempting to mislead House in regards to funding of firearms registry program, taking under advisement, 4220(71:1120), designation as major crown project not formally made by Treasury Board, incorrect to apply to firearms program, President of Treasury Board did not mislead House, not question of privilege, 4594(76:1500-5)
    >>>Solberg (rights of Members breached), National Defence Minister McCallum stated policy not to answer questions posed by Canadian Alliance Members, Members not able to fulfill roles as MPs, Members may not like answers received or quality of answers but Members do get responses, not question of privilege, 5041(83:1545)
    >>>Strahl (contempt of Parliament), Public Service Commission report on former Privacy Commissioner George Radwanski, briefing and release of report to media prior to briefing of Members of Parliament and tabling of report in House, taking under advisement, 7921(129:1505), 7997(130:1515), no statutory provision compelling Public Service Commission to table report in House, report made available to Members, not question of privilege, 8245-6(135:1015-20)
    >>>Toews (breach of House conventions), Solicitor General Easter specifically referring to matter before courts, possibly prejudicing fair trial of accused, taking under advisement, 6855(111:1510), Solicitor General response did not breach sub judice convention in significant way, Chair cautioning all Members to exercise greater discretion in debate and Oral Question Period, not question of privilege, 7281(118:1045)
    >>>Williams (contempt of Parliament)
    >>>>Justice Minister Cauchon releasing cost estimates and details of supplementary funding request of firearms registry program to media instead of House, taking under advisement, 4148(69:1515), information classified as briefing note, disclosure of this information does not constitute breach of privilege, 4495-6(74:1515-20)
    >>>>Pat Martin preparing to release minority report to Public Accounts Standing Committee draft report on government sponsorship program before committee meeting to discuss draft report, taking under advisement, 3363(56:1515), 3505(59:1005), no report from Committee, Chair cannot make judgement, reminding Members of obligation to respect confidentiality of committee proceedings, 3988-9(67:1505-10)
    >>Procedure
    >>>Adjournment of the House, June 13-Sept. 15, 2003, M. under S.O. 56.1 (Boudria), agreed to, 7299(118:1225)
    >>>Auditor General's Report, receiving when House adjourned, M. (Hearn), unanimous consent denied, 9195(151:1525)
    >>>Bills, Government
    >>>>Committee referral, Order Paper error, correction, 1201(21:1100)
    >>>>Committee referral, superceding motion, 72789118:1025)
    >>>>Report stage, proceeding with consideration of bill when Committee evidence not available in both official languages not in order, publication of Committee proceedings in both official languages not necessary for bills to be called, House to proceed with report stage of bill, 6811(110:1555), 6813(110:1615)
    >>>>Report stage, proceeding with consideration of bill when Committee evidence not available violation of fiduciary obligations of Parliament and Members to first nations, fiduciary obligations matter for debate, proceeding with bill at report stage, 6813-4(110:1615-25)
    >>>>Report stage motions
    >>>>>Grouping together, voting pattern, etc., 2667(44:1000), 2766(47:1020), 4220(71:1120), 6017(99:1005), 6063(100:1205)
    >>>>>Grouping too large, Members unable to speak to all motions in time limit, splitting, deferring consideration until matter reviewed by Chair, splitting into two groups, renumbering groupings, 2805-6(47:1515-25)
    >>>>>Member not present to move, 2767(47:1020-5)
    >>>>>Motion printed in Order Paper, wrong text used, deferring consideration until reviewed by Chair, printed text as submitted and signed by Member, putting to House as is, 2805(47:1515)
    >>>>>Not selected, 2766(47:1020), 3075(51:1540), 6017(99:1005), 6063(100:1205), 6888-9(112:1050-5), 6890-1(112:1115-20)
    >>>>>Selection criteria, 2766(47:1020), 6548-9(106:1600-5)
    >>>>>Withdrawal, 3990(67:1520), 4772(78:1515)
    >>>>Reprint, unanimous consent denied, 4922(81:1500)
    >>>>Same form as bills from previous session, reinstating at same stage as at prorogation, 517-9(8:1505-15)
    >>>>Second reading, amdt., in order, 3437(57:1625), 4524(75:1035)
    >>>>Senate dividing House of Commons bill into two different bills
    >>>>>Infringing on financial initiatives of the Crown and privileges of the House of Commons, taking under advisement, 2302(39:1125), in order, 2334-6(39:1500-10)
    >>>>>Message yet received, hypothetical, Chair will review at later date if necessary, 2267(38:11615)
    >>>>>Motion to concur in Senate message and waive House rights and privileges not in order, questions of legal or constitutional matters not dealt with by Chair, motion before House maintains rights and privileges but states House willing to waive in this case, motion properly before House, 5890-1(96:1720)
    >>>>>Motion to concur in Senate message regarding Bill C-10 not be considered a stage of a bill/Senate division of Bill C-10 not be considered an amendment, taking under advisement, 5186(85:1545), intrinsic part of legislative process, order, time allocation motion notice in order, 5363-4(88:1505)
    >>>Bills, Government, Senate, report stage, concurrence, agreed to, on divisions, by unanimous consent, 1910(32:1500)
    >>>Bills, Government, several stages at same sitting, 7278(118:1025), 7280(118:1040)
    >>>Bills, Government, Third reading, stage invalid, government reversing agreement reached in Committee to delete two clauses, not precedent for declaring stage invalid, opportunities to amend bill exist, 8280-1(135:1535-40)
    >>>Bills, Private Members' Public
    >>>>Deemed read second time, referred to committee, reported, report stage concurrence and read third time, 8525(140:1015)
    >>>>Introduction and first reading
    >>>>>Brief statement only, 4422(73:1520), 7661(125:1005), 7783(127:1020)
    >>>>>Microphone not functioning, 684(11:1505)
    >>>>>Several bills, introducing as group, 3508(59:1025)
    >>>>>Titles, dispensing with reading, 3508(59:1025)
    >>>>>Unanimous consent denied, 433(7:1005)
    >>>>Number designation, remaining same, by unanimous consent, 1504(25:1205), 1553(26:1505)
    >>>>>Denied, 805(13:1550)
    >>>>Royal Recommendation missing, not in order, taking under advisement, 8623(141:1835), no obligation for spending of public funds in bill, no need for Royal Recommendation, 8901-2(146:1505-10)
    >>>>Same form as bill from previous session, 139(3:1510), 143(3:1535), 685(11:1505), 1504(25:1205), 1743(29:1530)
    >>>>>Chair statement in error, correcting, 143(3:1535)
    >>>>Same subject as government bill, not in order, taking under advisement, 4494(74:1510)
    >>>>Sponsor, changing name, 3748u(63:1505), 4494(74:1510)
    >>>Budget
    >>>>Amendments, Minister not informing House, taking under advisement, 4044(68:1520), government within rights to change policy, ways and means motion must reflect changes in policy, 4370-1(72:1505-10)
    >>>>M. for approval, amdt., in order, 3757(63:1555)
    >>>Business of the House weekly questions, using to extend oral question period, not in order, 5110(84:1500)
    >>>Cellphones/pagers/noise-making devices, use in Chamber, not in order, 5709(93:1440)
    >>>Chamber lighting, malfunction, 1494(25:1115), 1617(27:1435)
    >>>Committee of the Whole House, proceeding to, 4070(68:1845)
    >>>Committees, Parliamentary
    >>>>Chair/Vice-Chair, election, meeting scheduled, 48 hour notice requirement not met, not in order, taking under advisement, 1311(22:1535), Chair ordering rescheduling, meeting 48 hour notice requirements, 1327(22:1740)
    >>>>Finance Standing Committee, Chair refusing to allow opposition members to follow/ask questions of witness, denial of freedom of speech and interfering with role as Member of Parliament, Committee Chair ruling appealed and sustained, Chair cannot overrule, Member able to raise questions at other committees, not point of order, 8638(142:1045)
    >>>>Witnesses, invitation to appear before, Prime Minister Office interference, Committee master of own procedures, may invite/call anyone it pleases, not point of order, 5717(93:1520)
    >>>Committees, Parliamentary, reports, concurrence motions
    >>>>Agreed to, by unanimous consent, 1913(32:1525)
    >>>>Leave to propose/move, unanimous consent denied, 686(11:1510)
    >>>>Moving under S.O. 56.1, wrong time and inappropriate method, taking under advisement, 759(12:1530), substantive motion should have been raised under rubric of Motions during Routine Proceedings and not Tabling of Documents; calling on a day other than that when unanimous consent denied in order; and not acceptable to consider committee report listing membership and associate membership of committees at beginning of new session as routine, 827-9(14:1005-15)
    >>>>Unanimous consent denied, 1036(17:1510)
    >>>Committees, Parliamentary, report, presenting/tabling
    >>>>Proceeding to, 9301(153:1005)
    >>>>Remarks/comments, not in order, 6610(107:1520)
    >>>>Reverting to, by unanimous consent, 1036(17:1510), 1742(29:1525)
    >>>>>Denied, 1953(33:1535), 4146(69:1500)
    >>>Conflict of interest, issue in which Committee Chair has direct pecuniary interest
    >>>>Committee Chair giving notice of motion for concurrence in report, point of order premature, only notice of concurrence motion given, motion may not be moved by Committee Chair or at all, 6094(100:1535), no grounds for ruling motion out of order, Committee Chair not voting on motion, debate may proceed, 7178-9(117:1025)
    >>>>Committee Chair possibly voting in favour of and signing report recommending payment of $30,000 to Member in support of action plan, taking under advisement, 5715(93:1510), report in procedurally acceptable form, Chair signed report to attest that the contents reflected the decision of the Committee and Chair absented himself from discussions and votes relating to matter, no conflict of interest found, 5988-9(98:1505-10)
    >>>Decisions/rulings of the Chair
    >>>>Discrepancies in statistics/figures used to arrive at decision, clarification requesting, taking under advisement, 3824(64:1505), matter best taken up with standing committee reviewing estimates of department, 3827(64:1530)
    >>>>Motion questioning authority of Speaker's decision, not in order, 6887-90(112:1050-110), 6891(112:1120)
    >>>Decorum, 1651(28:1420)
    >>>Decorum, noise/conversations/heckling, 11(1:1605), 18(2:1020), 131(3:1420), 245(4:1430), 248(4:1445), 362(6:1445), 516(8:1505), 582(9:1420-5), 586(9:1445-50), 749(12:1430), 800(13:1515), 1031(17:1435), 1075(18:1445), 1139(19:1420), 1300(22:1420), 1345(23:1425), 1350(23:1450), 1454(24:1435), 1548-9(26:1445-50), 1652(28:1430), 1732(29:1425-30), 2007(34:1420), 2009(34:1430), 2011(34:1440-5), 2107(36:1415), 2249(38:1425), 2326-7(39:1420), 2512(42:1410), 2515-6(42:1430), 2564(43:1530), 2627(44:1420), 2682(45:1140), 2685(45:1155), 3463(58:1420), 3464(58:1430), 3466(58:1440), 3745(63:1450), 3747(63:1455-500), 3985-6(67:1450-5), 4037(68:1440), 4251(71:1450), 4368(72:1455), 4413(73:1420), 4416(73:1445), 4531(75:1115), 4588(76:1430), 4658(77:1425), 4663(77:1455), 5032(83:1440), 5171(85:1430), 5204(85:1805), 5212(86:1035), 5259-60(88:1445-50), 5445-6(90:1420-5), 5635(92:1420), 5840(96:1045), 5984(98:1445), 6082(100:1425), 6319(103:1430), 6323(103:1450), 6607(107:1455), 6849(111:1435), 7023(114:1420), 7026(114:1435), 7135(116:1420), 7215(117:1440), 7293(118:1150), 7414(120:1435), 7704(125:1450-5), 7916(129:1440), 7994(130:1455), 8211(134:1445), 8318-9(136:1430-5), 8322(136:1450), 8482-3(139:1415-20), 8557(140:1420), 8561-3(140:1445-55), 8597(141:1420), 8602(141:1450), 8675(142:1450), 8842(145:1420), 8893(146:1425), 9141(150:1415)
    >>>Divisions, Chair declaring motion carried without announcing whether yeas or nays have it, motion declared carried, no Member rose to request recorded division, point of order declined, 3075(51:1540)
    >>>Divisions, deemed agreed to, on division, 8635(142:1005)
    >>>Divisions, recorded
    >>>>Abstentions, not recorded, 4686(77:1820)
    >>>>Adding name, 5873(96:1510)
    >>>>Chair voting to break tie vote, revisiting vote, requesting, reflecting on votes in House prohibited, 7439(120:1815)
    >>>>Declaring invalid, 8887(145:1910)
    >>>>Deferred, 1771(30:1005), 2041(35:1005), 2046(35:1040), 2673(45:1055), 2805(47:1515), 4523(75:1020), 5000(82:1535), 7034(114:1520), 8634(141:2000), 8756(144:1210)
    >>>>>Re-deferring, 2673(45:1055)
    >>>>Member having direct pecuniary interest in question, vote not counted, 8867(145:1755)
    >>>>Member not in Chamber when question called, vote not counted, 8867(145:1755)
    >>>>Member recorded as voting twice, indicating correct vote, 7436(120:1750)
    >>>>Members remaining in seats after voting, 8886-7(145:1905-15)
    >>>>Previously taken, applying to subsequent motions, 4019(67:1855), 4023(67:1925), 4025(67:1930), 4732(78:1710), 4733(78:1725), 4778(78:1925), 4997(82:1515), 5259(86:1555), 6163(101:1515), 6807(110:1535), 6809(110:1545), 7126(115:1835), 7482(121:1805), 8874(145:1805), 8876(145:1810)
    >>>>Procedure, M. (Jordan), unanimous consent denied, 1308(22:1505)
    >>>>Yeas and nays equal, Chair voting in negative so that Members may be given another opportunity to pronounce on the issue at another time, 7437(120:1800)
    >>>Documents, tabling
    >>>>Minister agreeing, failure to comply, documents tabled, 6248(102:1515)
    >>>>Minister citing, criteria, 4042-3(68:1510), 6036(99:1205), 6173(101:1610)
    >>>>Minister tabling wrong documents, dispute/debate, not point of order, 4493-4(74:1505)
    >>>>Unanimous consent, 4146(69:1505)
    >>>>>Denied, 1035(17:1505), 1147(19:1505), 1913(32:1520), 2115(36:1500), 3550(59:1500), 4421(73:1515), 5259(86:1555), 7220(117:1505)
    >>>Emergency debate, applications
    >>>>Accepted, debate ordered, 322(5:1230), 4261(71:1515), 5457(90:1520), 6443(105:1515)
    >>>>Emergency requirements/criteria not met, not accepted, 144(3:1540), 435(7:1010), 1738(29:1500), 1738(29:1500), 2266(38:1600), 2303(39:1130), 2521(42:1500), 3680(62:1005), 4925(81:1510), 7353(119:1545), 9201-2(151:1550)
    >>>>Keeping explanations brief and to the point, 2266(38:1600)
    >>>>Taking under advisement, 1699(29:1015), 2436(41:1515)
    >>>>Two applications on same subject
    >>>>>Chair hearing first submission only, 5456(90:1515)
    >>>>>First filed and withdrawn, refiled for another day, Chair hearing submission not withdrawn, 5456(90:1515)
    >>>Estimates
    >>>>Main, motion to restore item reduced by Transport Standing Committee, acceptability, clarification, 7031(114:1505)
    >>>>Supplementary, message from Governor General, proper order, 1109(19:1005)
    >>>Exhibits/props, use in Chamber, not in order, 5451(90:1455)
    >>>Government motions
    >>>>Acceptability, limitations, 1849(31:1555)
    >>>>Amdt., acceptability, direct negative of the main motion, will produce same result as defeat of motion and same effect as hoist of motion, amendment not direct negative of main motion or hoist but imposes condition on main motion, in order, 1984-5(34:1130)
    >>>>Amdt. to amdt., in order, 2045(35:1040)
    >>>>Chair dividing, 48 hour notice requirement for new motions, motion severed, not creating completely new set of motions, in order, 300(5:1010)
    >>>>Improperly before House, failure of government to accompany motion for ratification of treaty with copy of treaty, Canadian practice does not support argument, point of order not well taken, 1846(31:1535)
    >>>>Improperly before House, violation of decision approved earlier during supply motion debate, motion directed that action should be taken not must be taken, Chair proceeding with putting the motion to the House, 1826(31:1330-5)
    >>>>Improperly before House, not government motion as it instructs the government how to proceed, government cannot direct itself on how to proceed, removal from Order Paper requested, government may choose items under government motions, in order, 1956(33:1555)
    >>>>Improperly before House, violation of "rule of anticipation", rule not yet determined to be major part of parliamentary procedure at this time, point of order not taken 1848-9(31:1550)
    >>>>Omnibus in nature, four distinct and separate issues, requesting Chair divide into four separate motions, taking under advisement, 210(4:1020), issues related to the reinstatement of business from the first session to the second session will be debated together but will be the subject of two separate votes, the portion of the motion that empowers the finance committee to travel is not a matter of reinstating unfinished business and constitutes a stand-alone motion to be debated and voted on separately, 299-300(5:1000-10)
    >>>Government Orders
    >>>>Ending at 5:30 p.m., by unanimous consent, 6173(101:1610)
    >>>>Extending, 757(12:1515), 1310(22:1525), 1956(33:1555), 2213(37:1510), 2268(38:1620), 2525(42:1545), 2600(44:1100), 2805(47:1515), 3073(51:1530), 3143(52:1515), 3431(57:1530), 4667(77:1535), 4998(82:1515), 5874(96:1515), 6172(101:1600), 6549(106:1605), 6810(110:1550), 6923(112:1500), 8090(132:1210), 8491(139:1505)
    >>>Hansard
    >>>>Accuracy, discrepancies between video recording and way reported in Hansard, taking under advisement, 5178(85:1505), House decision regarding Private Members' motion accurately reported as carried, no interference from any member or member's office in preparation of final text of Hansard, "on division" not called nor did five Members rise to demand recorded vote, in interest of readability, Hansard office staff decided to eliminate some interventions and preserve those statements which reflected the decision the House ultimately arrived at, Chair requesting review of editorial decision process and the making of changes of render Debate more complete, 5364-5(88:1505-15)
    >>>>Accuracy, vote on Bill C-20, Progressive Conservative Party members votes improperly recorded, taking under advisement, 5453(90:1505)
    >>>>Changes in printed text from spoken word, altering meaning of statement, Prime Minister/Prime Minister Office involvement, taking under advisement, 3987(67:1505), 3990(67:1515)
    >>>House of Commons privileges and rights, motion waiving, acceptability, motion in order, 5187(85:1555)
    >>>House of Commons privileges and rights, motion waiving, outlining rights waived, Member may propose amendment to clarify motion, House will decide on rights and privileges waived, 5187(85:1555)
    >>>House of Commons visitors, presence in gallery, acknowledging, exclusive prerogative of Chair, 1081(18:1520)
    >>>House security breach, 1662(28:1535), 1744(29:1540)
    >>>Interparliamentary delegations, reports, presenting/tabling, reverting to, unanimous consent denied, 2764(47:1010)
    >>>Journals, accuracy, 366(6:1505)
    >>>Language, inappropriate/improper, 751(12:1440), 790(13:1415), 800(13:1515), 1074(18:1440), 1234(21:1450), 1549(26:1450), 2015(34:1500), 2204(37:1420), 4143(69:1445), 6241(102:1435), 7749(126:1455), 7988(130:1420), 8319(136:1435), 8603(141:1500)
    >>>>Aboriginal Affairs, Northern Development and Natural Resources Standing Committee Chair calling member "chien sale" and "enfant de chienne", withdrawal requested, 5069(84:0955), 5072(84:1025), taking under advisement, 5072(84:1030), language of this type not tolerated but matter for committee to deal with, 5197(85:1710) withdrawal requested, 5069(84:0955), taking under advisement, 5072(84:1030)
    >>>>Aboriginal Affairs, Northern Development and Natural Resources Standing Committee member threatening Committee chair with "we will get you, we will fix you", taking under advisement, 5143(85:1105)
    >>>>Fabrication, taking under advisement, 5453(90:1500), not unparliamentary, 5559-60(91:1500-5)
    >>>>"Fabricating facts, fabricating the truth, fabricated a statement," 6241(102:1435), 6247(102:1505-10)
    >>>>"Fuck off", 9080(149:1505)
    >>>>"He told me to f-off", taking under advisement, 5644(92:1515), nothing in blues or on video record of proceedings that violates rules concerning unparliamentary words, matter not formally raised by aggrieved member, matter closed, 5714(93:1505)
    >>>Member's remarks
    >>>>Addressing through Chair, 1907(32:1445), 4251(71:1455), 5243(86:1420), 5913(97:1435), 7382(120:1035), 7420(120:1515), 7708(125:1525), 8559(140:1430), 8710(143:1025), 8722(143:1140), 9264(152:1420)
    >>>>Casting aspersions, not in order, 9314(153:1135)
    >>>>Clarification, 2641(44:1540)
    >>>>False/misleading, 6247(102:1515), 6325(103:1505)
    >>>>False/misleading, apology requested, Chair's ruling on point of order closes matter, 5989(98:1515)
    >>>>False/misleading, debate, 1080(18:1520), 2640(44:1535), 4826(79:1510), 5259(86:1555), 5296(87:1500-5), 6036(99:1205), 6173(101:1610)
    >>>>Improperly directed, 4656(77:1415)
    >>>>Insulting/demeaning, 2802(47:1500), , 4070(68:1845)
    >>>>Issue debated earlier, matter for debate, 7(1:1530)
    >>>>Presence/absence of Member/Minister, not in order, 2758(46:1825)
    >>>>Reference to Members/Ministers by name, not in order, 141(3:1525), 362(6:1445), 514(8:1450), 5494(90:1955), 5643(92:1510), 7023(114:1420), 7415(120:1445)
    >>>>Relevance to debate, 7(1:1535), 591(9:1520), 2214-5(37:1520-30)
    >>>Ministerial briefing, schedule, providing short notice, government members briefed by Minister of Environment, opposition Members briefed by departmental staff, uneven, unequal treatment, meeting organized by Minister of Environment, outside of control of Chair, 1741-2(29:1520)
    >>>Moment of silence, 1503(25:1200), 8090(132:1210)
    >>>Motions
    >>>>Concurrence under S.O. 56.1, withdrawn as more than 25 members rose to object, 713(12:1000)
    >>>>Deemed adopted, 8040(131:1510)
    >>>Motions, leave to propose/move, 8(1:1545), 590(9:1510), 1238(21:1515), 1517(26:1105), 1913(32:1525), 1975(34:1005-10), 2060(35:1205), 2257(38:1505), 2336(39:1515), 2721(46:1505), 2765(47:1010), 2849(48:1520), 3781-3(64:1005-15), 4044(68:1520), 4146(69:1500), 4217(71:1105), 4719(78:1505), 4827(79:1515), 6327(103:1515), 7145(116:1520), 7176(117:1010), 7178(117:1020), 7275(118:1005), 7281(118:1050), 7296(118:1210), 7299(118:1225), 8039(131:1505), 8041(131:1520), 8523(140:1005), 9080(149:1510), 9196-7(151:1530-5)
    >>>>Unanimous consent denied, 520(8:1520), 686(11:1510), 806(13:1555), 2264(38:1600), 2268(38:1620), 2595(44:1035), 3187(53:1530), 3782(64:1010), 4421(73:1515), 4595(76:1510), 7280(118:1045), 9193(151:1515)
    >>>Motions, notice, improperly placed under Routine Proceedings, placing under notice of Private Members' Motions, 1871(32:1000)
    >>>Motions, reverting to, by unanimous consent, 4596(76:1515)
    >>>Ontario provincial budget, proposed presentation outside of legislature, not Chair's responsibility to make decisions about procedures in Ontario Legislature, 4221(73:1510)
    >>>Oral Question Period
    >>>>Minister taking extra time to make replies, limiting opportunities of Members to ask questions, 2015(34:1510)
    >>>>One question and one answer, 4660(77:1440)
    >>>Oral questions
    >>>>Allotted time, expired, 751(12:1445), 8485(139:1430), 8842(145:1420)
    >>>>Allowing Minister opportunity to reply, 6848(111:1430)
    >>>>Asked and replied to, moving to next question, 4365(72:1435)
    >>>>Asked of and replied to by political minister of province, precedent or not, 5643(92:1510)
    >>>>Beyond administrative scope/responsibility of department or minister, 915(15:1145), 919(15:1205), 2011(34:1440-5), 3745(63:1450), 3748(63:1505), 5247(86:1440), 5260(86:1555), 5983(98:1445), 5987(93:1505), 7214(117:1430), 7291(118:1145), 7624-5(124:1425), 8208(134:1430), 8214(134:1500), 8268(135:1420), 8777(144:1435), 8975(147:1455), 9077(149:1450), 9080(149:1505), 9142(150:1420)
    >>>>Directing to ministry through Chair, 680(11:1440)
    >>>>Former minister of department responding, setting precedent to ask questions of ministers about former portfolios, 4370(72:1505)
    >>>>Member putting to Minister concerning responsibilities in previous department/portfolio or capacity as political minister for province/region, acceptability, 1357-8(23:1535-40), questions out of order, Chair requesting Members be more judicious in choice of words in phrasing questions and to respect rules and practices of House, 1491(25:1055)
    >>>>Minister giving conflicting replies, debate, not point of order, 9194(151:1520)
    >>>>Minister inadvertently providing false information, Member using point of order to extend oral question period, other means available to raise matter, 5178(85:1510)
    >>>>Minister may respond, 2554(43:1435)
    >>>>Minister/Parliamentary Secretary replying from prepared text, turning Oral Question Period into press conference, Standing Order relating to speaking without prepared notes not enforced, 5043(83:1550-5)
    >>>>Minister releasing information refused previous day, not point of order, 4539(75:1205)
    >>>>Minister rejecting premise, debate, not point of order, 1913(32:1520)
    >>>>Must be directed to Ministers, 7622(124:1415)
    >>>>No question asked, moving to next questioner, 8599(141:1435)
    >>>>Not in order, 2112(36:1445), 2115(36:1500)
    >>>>Posing question, 8319(136:1435), 8971(147:1430)
    >>>>Preamble lengthy, 3246(54:1415), 4712(78:1430), 8719(143:1130)
    >>>>Quality of answer, New Zealand Speaker has authority to judge, extending to Speaker of Canadian House of Commons, 5042(83:1550)
    >>>>Replies, misleading, debate, 7535(122:1500)
    >>>>Reply, clarification, 2525-6(42:1545-50),
    >>>>Supplementary, Member opportunity to ask, 364(6:1450)
    >>>>Use of person's name, breach of rules, case not before courts, not point of order, 5042(83:1550)
    >>>Order Paper, omissions, reprinting, 6843(111:1405)
    >>>Orders of the Day, proceeding to, motion not in order, attempting to bypass routine proceedings without just cause, matter should have been raised before question put to House, proceeding with vote, 5839(96:1035)
    >>>Passports, constituent receiving passport not belonging to them, matter to discuss with Minister, not point of order, 1951(33:1520)
    >>>Petitions, tabling/presenting
    >>>>Brief summary only, 520(8:1525), 7462(121:1520), 8326(136:1515)
    >>>>Fifteen minute limit, extending, by unanimous consent, 2599(44:1055)
    >>>>Member supporting/opposing statement, 687(11:1520), 968(16:1525), 9197(151:1540)
    >>>>Not certified, not in order, 2598(44:1050)
    >>>>Not certified, presenting, by unanimous consent, 7223(117:1520)
    >>>>>Denied, 3653(61:1515), 7222(117:1515)
    >>>>Reverting to, by unanimous consent, 7221(117:1515)
    >>>Points of order
    >>>>Asking question, 4685(77:1810)
    >>>>Chair hearing after scheduled recorded division, 8635(142:1005)
    >>>>Debate, 2640(44:1535), 6890(112:1115)
    >>>>Member restricting remarks to procedural issues, 210(4:1020), 5071(84:1020)
    >>>>Not point of order, 2566(43:1545), 2640(44:1535)
    >>>Postal privileges, abuse by Member, recovery of costs, 6858(111:1535)
    >>>Privacy Commissioner Office, expenditures, false report to Parliament, government will attempt to verify 8116(132:1510), taking under advisement, 8215(134:1510)
    >>>Private Members' Business
    >>>>Member moving item speaking second time, closing debate, 7127(115:1850)
    >>>>Member unable to move item, dropped to bottom of order of precedence on the Order Paper, House continuing with other business before it, 2337(39:1515-20), 2641(44:1540), 2689(46:1100)
    >>>Private Members' Hour, cancelling/deferring, 4704(77:1920), 4778(78:1925), 7488(121:1910)
    >>>Private Members' Motions
    >>>>Votable, dropped to bottom of Order of Precedence, 6411(105:1205)
    >>>>Withdrawal, by unanimous consent, 1358(23:1545), 1743(29:1530)
    >>>Private Members' Motions for Production of Papers
    >>>>Called and agreed to, 6251(102:1520), 7464(121:1525)
    >>>>Called and transferred from debate, 3190(53:1540), 3751(63:1515), 6612(107:1530), 7464(121:1525), 9201(151:1550)
    >>>>Called and withdrawal requested, 6251(102:1525)
    >>>Privilege questions
    >>>>Member keeping remarks succinct and relevant to alleged breach of privilege, 1818-9(31:1235-40), 2300(39:1110), 2563(43:1525), 3474(58:1530)
    >>>>Member making future submission, Chair granting opportunity, 2259(38:1525)
    >>>>Member reserving right to raise, 2638(44:1525), 4826(79:1515), 6326(103:1505)
    >>>Routine Proceedings, reverting to, by unanimous consent, 4424(74:1505)
    >>>Question and comment period
    >>>>Allotted time
    >>>>>Expired, 14(1:1625)
    >>>>>First three speakers, not in order, 3434(57:1555)
    >>>>Chair passing over, 8850(145:1500)
    >>>>Requesting, unanimous consent denied, 2693(46:1135), 9305(153:1040)
    >>>Question be now put (previous question), Aboriginal Affairs, Northern Development and Natural Resources Standing Committee, in camera meeting, time allocation motion on floor, government member moving previous question, Committee Chair ruling out of order, ruling successfully appealed, requesting Speaker reverse decision to proceed with previous question motion, taking under advisement, 5072(84:1030), Chair cannot corroborate allegations as no access to transcript of in camera meeting, from available evidence proper procedures followed, Chair suggesting that question of appeal of committee chair rulings be referred to Modernization Committee, no need for Chair to intervene in affairs of Committee, 5186-8(85:1705-20)
    >>>Questions on the Order Paper
    >>>>Delay/failure to reply, departmental explanation to committee not Member, Member received reply, may not be satisfied, options available to correct, 6857-8(111:1530)
    >>>>Failure of Minister to respond within 45 day limit, referral to Standing Committee to review under S.O. 39(5), 2735(46:1530), 4596(76:1515), 6442(105:1515)
    >>>>Incorrect/incomplete reply, Chair cannot judge quality of replies, Member free to resubmit question, 4721-2(78:1510)
    >>>>Journals Branch, ruling portions out of order, Chair reinstating certain portions, 2565(43:1540)
    >>>>Number, amount of detail requested, failure to provide answers with 45 days, authority of Clerk to reject excessive demands, taking under advisement, 2723(46:1520), not possible for House staff to form any accurate assessment of resources necessary to prepare reply nor can they be charged with assessing the merits of the question, Chair cannot assess quality of replies however government must respond with 45 days or matter will be referred to standing committee for review, 3254-5(54:1505-15)
    >>>>Replies, insufficient, not providing full answer within 45 day limit, taking under advisement, 2849(48:1515), no provision in Standing Orders for Chair to review content of responses, 3256(54:1515)
    >>>Quorum, present, 2750(46:1725)
    >>>Simultaneous translation/interpretation, availability, 799-800(13:1510)
    >>>Sittings of the House, suspending, 4453(74:1000), 7282(118:1050)
    >>>Speaker's Chambers, reception, invitation, 2635(44:1500), 2640(44:1535)
    >>>Speeches, allotted time, expired, 8039-40(131:1510)
    >>>>Extending, 371(6:1545)
    >>>Spending authority, violation of procedures, heating fuel rebate, ex gratia payments, not listed in appropriations on annual basis, no legislative approval, taking under advisement, 7143(116:1505), ex gratia payments do not require specific parliamentary approval, in order, Chair concerned about adequacy of information provided to Parliament, suggesting Estimates Committee review information requirements, 7220-1(117:1505-10)
    >>>Statements by Members under S.O. 31, personal attacks, not in order, 5101(84:1410)
    >>>Statements by Ministers
    >>>>Government House Leader providing advance notice to media, prior to giving notice in House or to other House leaders, showing lack of respect to House and Members, taking under advisement, 319-20(5:1215)
    >>>>Members replying, time limits, equal to time taken to make statement, 1953-4(33:1535-40)
    >>>>Minister presenting statement prior to tabling documents, not in order, 3068(51:1500)
    >>>>National Defence Minister making policy statement at Toronto Board of Trade meeting, violation of Modernization and Improvement of Procedure of House of Commons Special Committee recommendations, Chair cannot compel Minister of make statement in House, not point of order, 919(15:1205)
    >>>>Natural Resources Minister making statement re softwood lumber outside of House, contempt of Members and Parliament, requesting Chair admonish, not within authority of Chair to compel Ministers to make statements on policy in House, 478(7:1510-5)
    >>>>Prime Minister statement on Canada participation in war with Iraq, making during Oral Question Period, not unusual occurrence, not point of order, 4253(71:1505)
    >>>>Reverting to, by unanimous consent, 80889132:1155)
    >>>Supply bills, distribution, 2303(39:1130), 4621(77:1005), 7176(117:1005)
    >>>Supply days, number allotted, 8(1:1545)
    >>>Supply motions
    >>>>Chair informing House of text of motion, 798(13:1505), 929(16:1105), 1263-4(22:1005-10), 1517(26:1105), 2256(38:1505), 3184(53:1500-5), 3471(58:1510), 4420(73:1505), 4521(75:1005), 4559(76:1100), 5036(83:1505), 5643(92:1510), 5918(97:1505), 6608-9(107:1505), 7143(116:1510), 7305(119:1105), 7460(121:1505), 7597(124:1105), 7889(129:1105), 8039(131:1505), 8604(141:1505), 8747(144:1105)
    >>>>Identical to recommendation in Standing Committee report, concurrence of which was moved earlier, motions cannot anticipate a matter standing on Order Paper for further discussion, opposition has right to move whatever motion it chooses on an opposition day, motion in order, 1149-50(19:1520-5)
    >>>>Notice of motion, withdrawn, 1147(19:1500)
    >>>>Two motions on Notice Paper, Chair to decide which takes precedence, 1082(18:1525), House practice to have never prevented consideration of more than one motion on an allotted day, procedural requirements of S.O. 81(14)(a) have been met, 1263(22:1005)
    >>>Throne Speech, Address in Reply
    >>>>Amdt., in order, 22(2:1055)
    >>>>Amdt. to amdt., in order, 29(2:1155)
    >>>Time allocation motion, 30 minute question period, 5840(96:1045)
    >>>Tributes, scheduling, 5178(85:1505)
    >>>>Reply, by unanimous consent, 9276(152:1540)
    >>>Vote, result contradicting previously passed motion, overturning, vote held, matter decided, 2526(42:1550)
    >>>Votes, value and validity, 1911-2(32:1505-10)
    >>Public Service, 2848(48:1510)
    >>Royal Assent, 2635(44:1505), 2652(44:1720), 3508(59:1025), 4422(73:1515), 4840-1(79:1715), 7143(116:1505), 9301(153:1000), 9328(153:1315)
    >>Throne Speech, 1-6(1:1525)
    >>Tremblay, Suzanne, references, 6855(111:1505)
    >>Wappel, references, 4778(78:1925)

Milliken-Oliver report see Ethics--"Proposals to amend the Rules of the Senate and the Standing Orders of the House of Commons to implement the 1997 Milliken-Oliver report"; Members of Parliament--Ethics

Mills, Bob (CA--Red Deer)

Previous Page Table of Contents Next Page